06/08/2006 - Structure Fire - Suncrest
Village
At 18:05 hours, Co. 20, 17, and 23 were
alerted for a structure fire at Suncrest Village. Initial
reports stated that there was three floors of one building on
fire. 20-3 arrived on scene and set up initial command.
After seeing the fire load 20-3 requested a tanker from every
company in the county and also added Co. 12, 13, 14, 3, and
Ladder 1 on the call. Ladder 1(Morgantown City) and Ladder
176(Granville) set up elevated master streams. More
details to come.
Click on Image for Larger View
|
|
|
Coutesy of the Dominion Post
|
|
|
|
Coutesy of the Dominion Post
|
|
|
|
Coutesy of the Dominion Post
|
|
|
|
Coutesy of the Dominion Post
|
|
|
|
Coutesy of the Dominion Post
|
|
|
|
|
Coutesy of the Dominion Post
|
|
|
|
Coutesy of the Dominion Post
|
|
|
|
Coutesy of the Dominion Post
|
|
|
|
Coutesy of the Dominion Post
|
|
|
|
Coutesy of the Dominion Post
|
|
|
|
|
|
amatear pictures heading to fire
|
|
|
|
amatear pictures heading to fire
|
|
|
|
amatear pictures heading to fire
|
|
|
|
amatear pictures heading to fire
|
|
|
|
amatear pictures heading to fire
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Courtesy of the Westover VFD
|
|
|
|
Courtesy of the Westover VFD
|
|
|
|
Courtesy of the Westover VFD
|
|
|
|
Courtesy of the Westover VFD
|
|
|
|
Courtesy of the Westover VFD
|
|
|
|
|
Courtesy of the Westover VFD
|
|
|
|
Courtesy of the Westover VFD
|
|
|
|
Courtesy of the Westover VFD
|
|
|
|
Courtesy of the Westover VFD
|
|
|
Below are articles that have run in the Dominion
Post related to the fire
Condo fire
Four buildings
destroyed at luxury complex
BY ERIC BOWEN AND JANET METZNER
The Dominion Post
A massive fire destroyed four unoccupied buildings at the
newly constructed
Suncrest
Village condominium complex off W.Va. 705 on Thursday.
Two occupied buildings and a clubhouse closest to the road
received only heat damage, said Ron Skidmore, assistant fire
chief for Star City Volunteer Fire Department. No injuries were
reported either from firefighters or residents of the complex.
The cause of the fire was unknown.
The fire started at about 6 p.m. in a building under
construction at the back end of the complex, Skidmore said.
Firefighters fought the blaze for about two hours before it was
contained. The fire continued to smolder into Thursday night.
Skidmore said 10 fire departments
responded to the blaze, including nine volunteer fire
departments and the Morgantown Fire Department. Three other
volunteer fire departments were put on stand-by and moved closer
to the fire.
Morgantown Chief Dave Fetty said two trucks from his
department helped fight the fire.
Skidmore said the fire was one of
the worst he had seen in 14 years in the fire service.
“This is in the top five I’ve seen in my career,” he said.
“Just about every fire department in the county was here.”
Sharon Stratton, who lives in one of the Suncrest Village
buildings near the blaze, said she smelled smoke and grabbed her
purse and passport before running away from the building. But
she noticed that no one had tripped the fire alarm, so she went
back inside to make sure her neighbors got out OK.
“I saw black smoke and I knew this would
be terrible,” Stratton said. “Most of us just got out with our
clothes.”
Courtney Toman saw smoke from her back window and then heard
the fire alarm go off in the complex. She grabbed her keys and
ran out of the house.
Toman said her condominium was the first real estate she ever
owned. She watched the fire progress from a hill above the
complex.
“This is no longer a fire drill,” she said. “I’m thinking I’m
getting kind of sick. I got insurance two days ago.”
Shortly after firefighters arrived on
the scene, black smoke poured out of the development and
dominated the horizon for miles. Red and yellow flames shot into
the air as firefighters sprayed water from two ladders above the
blaze.
Across town, ashes and embers rained down on the parking lot
at
Hazel
Ruby McQuain Park by the Monongahela River, one The Dominion
Post reader reported.
Morgantown
resident Julia Weimer was driving to her Suncrest home at about
6:20 p.m. when she saw the fire from W.Va. 705. She saw flames
burning low at one building, and firefighters on the scene.
“I was about to cry — it always saddens me to know someone
could be losing everything,” she said.
The smoke was visible from
Westover, and some patrons of the West Virginia Brewing LLC on
University Avenue were outside the pub, pointing up at the
smoke, wondering what was causing it.
During the fire, the wind shifted and threatened to ignite
the remaining two buildings, Skidmore said, but firefighters
were able to save them. Several pieces of construction equipment
on the site were also burned.
The event caused gridlock along W.Va. 705 as evening
commuters pulled their cars over to the ample berms, a MECCA 911
dispatcher said.
“It looked worse than a football
game night with all the cars pulled off the road, onto the berm,”
Weimer said. WVU Mountaineer football fans often park along
W.Va. 705 and walk a mile or more to the Milan Puskar Stadium.
Four Monongalia County Sheriff’s Deputies as well as police
officers from WVU helped control traffic, and numerous cars were
towed, the 911 dispatcher said.
Another MECCA 911 dispatcher said gawkers blocked W.Va. 705
so much that the road had to be closed.
“People were just stopping everywhere, in the roadway too,”
she said.
The road was closed after 6:30 p.m. when the first sheriff’s deputy arrived on scene, and was
re-opened at
9 p.m.,
she said.
There were no arrests, she said.
And no one was transported to the hospital, “as far as I
know,” she said at about 10:20 p.m. However, an ambulance was
still standing by, she said.
“Once the buildings caught on fire, it did cause a brush fire
— a very large brush area,” she said.
The development, visible from W.Va. 705, and on Maple Drive,
consisted of four apartment buildings with 24 units each, as
well as a 6,500-square foot community center and a maintenance
building.
Neither the community center nor the maintenance building was
affected, said a dispatcher with Secure U.S., a Morgantown
company that provides security systems to those buildings, but
not the dwelling units. The Red Cross from
Morgantown
was sent to the fire as well. The Red Cross
took water, meals for firefighters, and offered other services,
a MECCA 911 dispatcher said. Firefighters had a good
supply of water to fight the fire, said Jim Green, general
manager for Morgantown Utility Board.
“They are moving as much water as they can out of our system.
The fire department indicated that they
were getting plenty of water,” he said. “County tankers are
hauling some water from somewhere.”
The fire caused no disruption to electric service in the
area, said Allen Staggers, Allegheny Power spokesman.
“The only thing affected by the fire is the apartments
themselves. Typically when we respond to a fire we’ll try to cut
the power to the residents,” he said.
A service technician from Dominion Hope, a natural gas
provider, was probably among the first to notice the smoke.
“We had our service personnel (Hobie Butcher) responding to
the area, said Bob Fulton, Dominion Hope spokesman. “As a matter
of fact, he spotted the smoke, had a sense that something was
wrong and went to the scene and took the initiative to get the
gas turned off at the complex.”
He found the problem so early, that “when 911 called to ask
us to respond to the scene, we said the service personnel had
already isolated the complex.”
No other customers or areas were affected, Fulton said.
The
Suncrest
Village condominiums are being developed by 705 Five Development
Group. Partners are David Biafora, Rick Biafora, Larry Palumbo,
Pat Alexander and Bob Toth.
Speaking to a The Dominion Post reporter on the scene, Dave
Biafora said that his company would put residents up in hotels
overnight.
None of the others could be reached for comment, and none
returned calls left by The Dominion Post.
Some of the developers were on site during the fire. They
stood in a group but, other than Dave Biafora, would not speak
to the media, members of the W.Va. State Police told The
Dominion Post.
The complex, on 50 acres, is billed as luxury condominiums.
One-bedroom units start at $109,900, and two-bedrooms begin
at $157,900. One-bedroom units are about 650-799
square feet, and two-bedrooms approximately 1,075-1,159 square
feet.
All units offer nine-foot ceilings with crown molding,
oversized baseboards, fireplaces, bay windows with window seats
and private decks.
The units are prewired for security and have deed-assigned
parking spaces.
Suncrest
Village was planned to have 18 buildings, with 24 units per
building in the one- and two-bedroom complexes. The
three-bedroom buildings were designed to have 20 units.
Two Realtors are listing agents for the units, according to
the Suncrest Village Luxury Condominiums Web site
www.morgantowns.com.
Realtor Anna Marie Stephens said, “I have no time to discuss
it. Thank you,” before hanging up her phone. Stephens is a
Realtor with Howard Hanna Premier Properties by Barbara
Alexander LLC, in Cranberry Square, Morgantown.
The associate on call at Howard
Hanna did not return a message left on the answering system.
Renee Z. Gatian, Realtor, also of that group, could not be
reached for comment.
Mon County Commissioner Bob Bell said that, according to his
information, 56 units had been sold, and 30 of the units were
occupied.
“Certainly any time you have a fire of this magnitude it’s a
tragedy in the community. And I hope nobody was hurt. And I hope
they had enough insurance coverage to cover the loss,” Bell
said.
705 Five is also the developer of 102-acre, $50 million
Suncrest Towne Centre, a “lifestyle center” located just across
W.Va. 705, on the old Straight Farm, a property Wal-Mart once
sought for a Supercenter.
For this project, the developers are legally known as Gateway
Towne Centre, the name they had once called the project.
The development will be mostly
retail. Plans include a cinema, 150,000 square feet of office
space overlooking the center, restaurants, a bank and other
businesses.
The fire is under investigation by the state Fire Marshal,
said Ryan Thorne, deputy director of the Monongalia County
Office of Emergency Management.
Investigators search condo ruins
Agencies seek cause of devastating fire at Suncrest Village
BY GARY GRAY The Dominion Post
Investigators are looking into the cause
of a fire that consumed four buildings Thursday in the
Suncrest Village condominium complex.
State Fire Marshals, U.S. Alcohol Tobacco, Firearms and
Explosives agents, local fire officials, and members of the
705-Five Development Group began the inquiry Friday among
smoldering remains.
“Several people from my office and the ATF are inside [the
community center] making a general plan,” said John McGinnis,
assistant fire marshal. “All indications are that the fire
started in the lower units [northwest side]. We’re taking
pictures, and we’re also talking to witnesses and firefighters
that were on the scene. But it’s going to be days before we know
anything.”
The fire destroyed four of six buildings within the complex.
These buildings each contained 24 units.
The two buildings not destroyed were partially occupied, but
they were quickly evacuated and no injuries were reported.
Mon County Commissioner Bob Bell
said that, according to his information, 56 units had been sold,
and 30 of those units were occupied.
705-Five partner David Biafora said that some people
displaced by the fire returned to their dwellings Friday. He
also expects most people will return in a relatively short time.
“They could come back right now,” he said. “The damage to
their buildings was very minor, with some paint peeling and a
little chipping on the outside. In fact — I don’t know if this
is good or bad — but we sold a couple more units today.”
Insurance covers buildings
The group and condominium owners are covered through two
separate types of insurance policies, David Biafora said.
“The project itself is covered by what
is called ‘builder’s risk’ insurance,” he said. “We pay for that
while construction is under way. When a unit is occupied, the
owner pays dues to Suncrest Village Homeowners Association. In
turn, the association uses some of that money on a policy that
covers them. It’s a typical insurance plan for townhouses.”
Michael S. Garrison, an attorney representing 705-Five
Development Group, released a statement on behalf of the group
Friday after-
noon. He thanked the Morgantown Fire
Department and all surrounding area volunteer fire departments.
“Because of their quick action and immediate response,
residents of the property were not harmed and no lives were
lost,” Garrison wrote. “Residents have been relocated
temporarily to the Waterfront Place Hotel at the expense of the
705-Five Development Group. In addition, the partners are
pleased that the two completed buildings sustained almost no
damage due to the integrity of their construction.”
Neither Biafora nor Garrison gave estimates on the cost of
damages.
As officials formulated an investigation plan from inside an
office building, firefighters bulldozed debris into piles and
workers replaced bits of roofing on buildings that received only
minor damage.
Security at the site was rigid, with
Rick Raspa & Associates shooing away media and onlookers.
“Leave now, or go to jail,” Raspa shouted.
Raspa later told The Dominion Post he was providing security for
705-Five Development Group and apologized for being abrupt.
“The ATF doesn’t want anybody on the property while the
investigation is going on,” he said. “Secondly, there is a
safety factor to consider.”
The fire started at about
6
p.m. Thursday and firefighters fought the
blaze for about two hours before it was contained.
Nine volunteer fire departments and the Morgantown Fire
Department responded to the blaze. Three other volunteer fire
departments were put on stand-by and moved closer to the fire.
“I was the first one here,” said Jason Quinn, Star City
Volunteer Fire Department chief. “I pulled off Poultry Farm Road
(which leads to the condominiums) and started helping them hook
up the hydrants. I was in my personal truck. It was so hot you
could feel the heat from hundreds of yards away.”
The condominiums sit on a 50-acre site outside the Morgantown
city limits. Plans for
Suncrest
Village included 18 buildings, with 24 units per building in the
one- and two-bedroom complexes. Three-bedroom buildings were
designed to have 20 units.
The fire displaced not only
condominium owners but workers as well.
Preston
County resident Ray Renshaw was visibly upset Friday when he
pulled out of the site with what may be his last paycheck for
some time.
“I was hired by a Morgantown company just three days ago to
do trim work,” he said.
“I came to get my check today, and they told me that they
would contact me — maybe in December. This is like my 9/11. This
job was my saving grace.”
Chief: Condo village had hydrant shortage
Quinn wants developers, VFDs to work together
BY JANET L. METZNER The Dominion Post
ANYONE WHO
has information on the
Suncrest
Village fire is asked to call the arson hotline at (800)
233-3473.
One more hydrant may have helped
fight the fire Thursday at Suncrest Village Condominium complex,
Star City Chief Jason Quinn said.
“If we had one extra hydrant, could we have saved one more
building? I honestly don’t know. We would have had a better
chance of it though,” he said.
Suncrest
Village, off W.Va. 705, is in Star City VFD’s service area.
On Thursday evening, Quinn coordinated the efforts of
firefighters from nine
Monongalia
County volunteer fire departments and the Morgantown Fire
Department to battle the blaze that consumed four unoccupied
condominium buildings.
Firefighters used the one fire
hydrant in front of the Suncrest Village office, but the other
hydrant was so far away it could have contributed to water
pressure problems that night, Quinn said. It was located over a
hillside, down by the lowest point of the property.
Firefighters had to stretch a couple thousand feet of fire
hose to get the hydrant’s water to the scene. Usually, one
pumper truck carries 1,400 feet of 4-inch hose, he said.
“Water traveling through a hose causes friction, that loses
pressure at the pump itself,” he said. “When you have to stretch
out thousands of feet of water hose, just to get a water supply,
that, to me, is a very bad thing,” Quinn said.
Firefighters had to use
additional water from the swimming pool, and four to six tanker
trucks continually brought in more water from the hydrant in
front of Suburban Lanes, Quinn said.
Monday, Quinn called for developers in the county to consult
with their fire departments and Morgantown Utility Board about
where to place fire hydrants.
“I wish that the developers would contact the fire
departments to work with the utility board to work on hydrant
placement,” he said. “It would be in a developer’s
best interest for the protection of their
property to consult the fire department and MUB jointly, to see
that there is an adequate number of hydrants on any property
that is built,” he said.
Quinn said developers of The District Apartments, another
complex in Star City VFD’s service area, “gave me carte blanche”
in suggesting where to put hydrants.
He said he marked on their plans every place he would like to
have a hydrant, and they put them there.
“Ultimately, (The District) is probably one of the best
covered properties in the county as far as hydrants,” Quinn
said.
“In my opinion, if someone wants to build a 10-unit apartment
complex, they should come to us (VFDs) and ask,” he said.
Quinn said he will send a letter to Commissioner Asel Kennedy
requesting that apartment complex developers be required to consult
with VFDs and MUB regarding hydrant placement.
Kennedy said it’s a good idea that developers consult their
VFD on hydrant placement, and he hopes that more do so.
Developers already consult with MUB on development plans,
Kennedy said. For example, the developers of Suncrest Village
consulted with MUB about the hydrants there.
Kennedy said the commission will
likely address the issue at their meeting June 21 or June 28,
but probably not earlier.
Commissioners need time to research the issue before they
make suggestions, he said.
The
Suncrest
Village fire burned for two hours and destroyed four unoccupied
condominium buildings. The two occupied condo buildings and the
community center received some heat damage.
After spending a night away from their home, residents were
allowed back in the two occupied condominium buildings Friday.
County
Commission President Bob Bell has said
that, according to his information, 56 units had been sold, and
30 of them were occupied.
Two more had been sold Friday, said David Biafora, one of the
partners in 705 Five developers.
Partners are Biafora, Rick Biafora, Pat Alexander, Larry
Palumbo and Bob Toth.
David Biafora, who has acted as spokesman for the group, and
Mike Garrison, attorney for the group, could not be reached for
comment Monday.
The W.Va. Fire Marshal’s Office continues investigating the
cause of the fire, said Kim O’Brien, secretary for the
investigation division of the W.Va. Fire Marshal’s Office.
“At this point in time, all I can say is that it does remain
under active investigation by our office as
well as the ATF,” O’Brien said. The ATF is the U.S. Bureau of
Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives.
Anyone who has information on the fire, is asked to call the
Arson hotline at (800) 233-3473.
“That does not necessarily mean it has been determined as
arson. We have not ruled (a cause) on the fire at all,” O’Brien
said.
Quinn said that, when he arrived at the scene, he saw one
building fully involved in the fire, and one partially involved.
He said he did not know where the fire started, though, because
the two buildings behind them were not visible to him.
He said it took some time for him to make his way to the
back, to see those other buildings.
“The investigation will find that
(the order of the buildings catching fire) out,” he said.
State Fire Marshal Sterling Lewis confirmed that he does not
know what caused the fire, or where it started.
Lewis said he did not know if the electricity was hooked up
to the unoccupied buildings that burned. “We don’t know. We
haven’t finished investigating it yet. We have to be thorough,
he said.
He said the ATF is involved because “they like to get in with
us when we have a large dollar loss.”
The amount of loss has not been confirmed. The buildings each
contained 24 units. One-bedroom units are priced for sale at
$109,900, and two-bedroom units begin at $157,900.
Condominium’s fire hydrant questions continue
Officials concerned about numbers, locations at condos
BY JANET L. METZNER The Dominion Post
Workers hosed off dozens of white
plastic lawn chairs Tuesday, stacked in front of the community
center building at
Suncrest Village.
Five days earlier, a fire destroyed four incomplete,
unoccupied condominium buildings there. Two occupied ones were
spared.
An area rug hung on a thirdfloor condominium railing, and
construction continued just outside the gates to the complex, as
workers graded a roadway.
In contrast, the back of the complex resembled a war zone.
The foundations, topped by arches
and decorated with brown and beige stone were all that remained
of the former buildings.
Ruined drywall and black ash had been separated into piles
beside one of the charred structures. Large trash bins held
grayish rubble from the fire.
Several pieces of construction equipment stood where they had
been before the fire started at about 6 p.m. Thursday. Their
tires melted during the blaze, leaving wheels embedded in the
dusty ground.
Within the destroyed buildings, steel I-beams hung bowed, and
twisted or broken from the intense heat of the fire.
Star City Fire Chief Jason Quinn coordinated the firefighting
efforts Thursday, because the complex is in his Star City
volunteer fire department’s service area.
Quinn said an additional hydrant may
have helped fight the fire, but placement of the existing two
hydrants was the main problem.
Namely, one was so far away that a couple of thousand feet of
hose had to be used to access it. That length of hose likely
caused friction of the water passing through, causing periods of
weak flow, Quinn said.
Firefighters from nine county volunteer fire departments and
the Morgantown Fire Department battled the blaze, Quinn said.
Firefighters used about 750,000 gallons of water to battle
the catastrophic fire, said general manager Jim Green of the
Morgantown Utility Board.
That estimate is based on the amount of water used from MUB
tanks, and the amount being pumped into the system during the
time the fire was fought, Green said.
They used the two hydrants on site, and tanker trucks brought
in water from a hydrant nearby, and to the hydrant in front of
Suburban lanes, Green said.
Quinn said Monday that the size of the lines could have
contributed to the problem as well. He said he does not know the
size of the water lines.
“One of our engines that was supplied by a hydrant ...
dropped below the acceptable intake pressure several times and
had to be shut down,” he said.
He said about five engines were pumping water at any given
time, including pumping water from a dump tank — a foldable
container on the ground, that can hold a couple thousands of
gallons of water. The tank is used for back-up water supply, he
said.
On Monday, Quinn called for
developers in the county to meet with their VFD and MUB to
review development plans, and where hydrants should be put.
Quinn said the developers of The District apartments did
that, and now have some of the best hydrant coverage in the
county.
On Tuesday morning, Green agreed that developers should talk
with VFDs about placing hydrants.
“This was a catastrophic fire. It
comes down to ‘How many streams of water can you put on that
fire?’ if you’ve got just a limited number of locations where to
put that hose. ... You need to get a firefighter’s opinion if
you are going to build a densely-populated set of buildings.”
Green said the utility does not consult on how many hydrants
are needed for fighting fires — that’s firefighters’ area of
expertise.
And property owners are responsible for how many hydrants are
placed on their property to access the water available, he said.
“Public or private fire protection are all up to the owners of
the properties.
“When developers come in with plans for development, they
locate their hydrants where they want to. MUB’s dog isn’t even
in that fight,” Green said.
The two hydrants at Suncrest Village
did the job they were supposed to do Green said. Together, they
put out “over 4,000 gallons per minute,” Green said. “They had
more than enough.” An acceptable amount is about 2,500 per
hydrant for commercial property, he said. The development could
use more hydrants, he said. One hydrant, which firefighters said
was far away from most of the fire, was located six paces from
one of the buildings that burned, Green said. It was located at
the lowest point of the complex. “They (firefighters) probably
didn’t get to that one (at first) because it was too hot
initially,” Green said.
Green said the Suncrest Village
hydrants have excellent water capacity because MUB’s tank on the
old WVU orchard property is only about a mile away. A 16-inch
main water line extends from the tank along W.Va. 705 toward the
medical center. An 8-inch line off of that main supplies
Suncrest Village, Green said. The hydrants are connected to 6-
inch lines, the national standard, he said.
“They didn’t have a shortage of water. It was available. They
didn’t have the places to connect. That’s why they (the VFD) say
they need more hydrants,” Green said.
Mike Garrison, attorney for Suncrest Village developers
705-Five, said Tuesday evening that there were enough hydrants,
but disagreed with Green regarding responsibility.
“We feel confident the two buildings were saved because we
did have adequate fire hydrants there,” Garrison said.
“It’s really not the developers’ fire system. The Morgantown
Utility Board played a role in that.”
When asked what role, Garrison said, “They designed and
approved it. It is my understanding that MUB designs the fire
hydrant system and operates the fire hydrant system as the
utility board,” he said.
When asked if more hydrants are
planned for the development, Garrison said, “I don’t know. I
think that would depend on how many buildings go in. Again, the
plans are approved by MUB. Systems approved by MUB. We will do
everything we are asked to do by the utility company.”
When asked what insurance company insures 705-Five, Garrison
said he could not answer because the investigation is ongoing.
The W.Va. Fire Marshal’s Office and the federal Bureau of
Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives are investigating.
Green said all the buildings on site at the time of the fire
had sprinkler systems. But the four buildings that burned did
not have the sprinkler systems turned on. That’s because the
buildings were not far enough along in their construction.
The occupied buildings’ sprinkler systems were on, and would
have helped save those buildings if they had been needed, Green
said.
Quinn: Hydrants essential
Developments make safety a top priority
BY JANET L. METZNER The Dominion Post
Buck Jennings describes a common fear
among builders.
“Every contractor there is — every night closes his eyes and
wonders if everything will be there in the morning.”
Jennings,
construction superintendent for Fountain View condominiums, said
buildings under construction are vulnerable. It’s a different
story after they’re completed and people move in — because
sprinkler systems are on and protect from fire damage.
At Fountain View, being developed by
Fountain View LLC, one building is complete and three are
framed, Jennings said. To make sure Fountain View is fire
protected, Jennings asked Fire Chief Jason Quinn, of the Star
City Volunteer Fire Department, to visit the property.
On Tuesday, he showed Quinn the one existing hydrant, and
where he wants to put in a “dry hydrant” that will pull
thousands of gallons of water from the property’s retention
ponds. Two additional hydrants are also planned along with the
development, Jennings said.
He had planned to do this earlier, but was galvanized to
action by a fire at another developer’s property — Suncrest
Village.
The fire, less than two weeks ago and just a few miles away,
destroyed four condominium buildings under construction by
705-Five Development Group.
Quinn led nine of 12 Monongalia County
volunteer fire departments and the Morgantown Fire Department in
battling the blaze. Days afterward, Quinn urged developers to
meet with their local fire department and the Morgantown Utility
Board to plan how many hydrants there should be, and where to
put them.
That’s because the two fire hydrants on the Suncrest Village
property weren’t enough, Quinn said. One was so far away that
firefighters had to use several thousand feet of hose. The
distance may have contributed to low water pressure that forced
firefighters to shut down one engine several times, he said.
Quinn said he is glad to see developers are getting his
message.
“It’s just good to know that some of the developers are
finally taking fire safety as a priority and consulting with
us,” he said.
Fountain View has several fire safety measures in place.
These include a sprinkler system, an alarm
system with fire box to show where the fire is, and pull
stations at all entrances to alert residents of a fire,
Jennings said.
Fountain View isn’t alone in asking for the VFD’s help, Quinn
said. During the planning stages of The District Apartments,
which opened last year, developers there asked Quinn for help
placing hydrants.
That development, Quinn said, now has the best hydrant
coverage in the county.
Were there enough hydrants?
Whether there were enough hydrants at Suncrest Village has been
an issue of debate since the fire.
Morgantown
attorney Mike Garrison, who represents the developers of
Suncrest Village, 705-Five Development Group, has said devel-
opers are confident there were enough
hydrants there.
Quinn disagrees.
“My stance is that there were not enough hydrants to hook up
to,” he said, adding that the more than 4,000 gallons per minute
that MUB said the hydrants produced weren’t enough, either.
A building that size requires 9,745 gallons per minute — for
just one building, Quinn said.
County tankers hauled in water from several other hydrants,
one in front of Suburban Lanes on W.Va. 705.
MUB General Manager Jim Green said they used a hydrant
located nearby on
Maple Drive,
as well.
The Suncrest Village fire
investigation continued Tuesday, with the U.S. Bureau of
Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives still on the scene, as
well as insurance investigators, Quinn said.
Quinn said he is not certain if the state Fire Marshal’s
Office is still investigating. The office was closed Tuesday,
and no one could be reached for comment.
Green said MUB does not consult about the number of hydrants
necessary. That’s up to property owners to protect their
property.
He noted that the two hydrants at Suncrest Village did the
job they were designed to do — putting out more than 4,000
gallons per minute.
An acceptable amount is about 2,500 gallons per minute, per
hydrant for commercial property, he said.
However, the development could use more hydrants, to access
more of the water available, he said.
Suncrest met guidelines
Erie Insurance insures
Suncrest
Village, said Mark Dombrowski, spokesman for
Erie.
He said
Erie
underwrites based on ISO standards, which include accessibility
to fire hydrants and how close a fire company is located form
the property.
“In those instances their fire protection also was within our
underwriting guidelines,” Dombrowski said.
ISO is a company that supplies data and decision-support
services in various fields. For example, it analyzes fire
departments on fire protection services, and rates them for
insurance purposes.
Quinn said that each fire
department has an ISO rating based on information such as
response times for past calls, how well the area is covered by
hydrants and the 911 system.
Insurance companies base a developer’s insurance premiums on
that rating, Quinn said.
Dombrowski said Erie also considers a developer’s
insurability.
Dombrowski said he could not give details on the Suncrest
Village insurance policy. He also did not know if there are
supplemental policies.
“At this point, it still is a claim under investigation,” he
said.
Quinn said he went out to Suncrest Village during its early
construction stages to verify that sprinklers and fire alarm
systems were planned, and to assure there would be proper “fire
barriers” — including doors, walls and floors that can slow the
progress of a fire.
It met those standards, he said.